Side by Side
What works for one person may not work for another
A list of nine products is only half the job. Several of these look alike in a photo and solve different problems, and the mistakes families make are almost always between two things that seem similar. Five comparisons that come up every week:
Bathtub security pole or electric bath lift: which one do we need?
Short answer: the pole is for balance, the lift is for strength. A bathtub security pole gives a person something solid to hold while they step over the tub wall, lower themselves and stand up; they still do the work.
A bath lift does the lowering and raising for them, but does nothing about the tub wall. Someone with weak knees but good balance may do fine with the pole. Someone who cannot push up from a low position needs the lift, and may still want a handhold for the step in. They are not substitutes for each other; some households end up with both.
VOCIC AX07 vs. AX08: what is actually different?
Short answer: the same lift range, a different seat. Both lower to about 2.3 inches and rise to about 18.9 inches, both carry 300 lb, and both run on a rechargeable waterproof hand control. The AX08's seat is two inches wider and almost three inches longer, which makes it the better floor lift and the better choice for a broader user; the AX07 is three pounds lighter and fits narrower tubs.
| Specification | AX07 | AX08 |
|---|
| Weight capacity | 300 lb | 300 lb |
| Product weight | about 23 lb | about 26 lb |
| Lowest seat height | about 2.3 in. | about 2.3 in. |
| Highest seat height | about 18.9 in. | about 18.9 in. |
| Listed seat width | 13.4 in. | 15.4 in. |
| Listed seat length | 17.7 in. | 20.5 in. |
| Product page | AX07 specifications | AX08 specifications |
If the tub is narrow or the lift will be carried in and out often, the AX07. If anyone in the house may need help up from the floor, or the user is broad through the hips, the AX08.
Toilet safety rail or bedside commode?
Short answer: if the toilet itself is fine and the person just needs arms, the rail; if distance, urgency or seat height is the problem, the commode. A toilet safety rail stays in the bathroom and leaves the toilet exactly as it was, which most people prefer.
A commode changes the equation in two ways a rail cannot: it can live beside the bed, and, set over the toilet, it raises the seat by several inches. The limitation runs the other way too: a rail cannot help someone who is not reaching the bathroom in time, and a commode over the toilet takes up floor space the other people in the house will notice.
Fixed-arm commode or drop-arm commode?
Short answer: it depends on how the person gets onto the seat. Fixed arms, like those on the McKesson 3-in-1, are rigid and reassuring for someone who stands, turns and sits; they also cost less. They are a wall for someone who transfers sideways from a wheelchair. A drop-arm model like the Lumex Versamode lowers one side so the person slides across; the VOCIC YR11's flip-up arms do a similar job for a standing-assisted transfer. Choose by the transfer, not by the price.
Shower transport chair or wheeled commode: aren't they the same thing?
Short answer: no, and this one causes the most expensive mistakes. The two Lumex chairs in this guide look alike: both have wheels, both have an open seat, both are meant to be pushed by a caregiver. The shower transport chair has an anodized aluminum frame built for water, rear wheel locks, and is meant to be rolled into a roll-in shower.
The Versamode is a transfer and transport commode with drop arms and a pail; its listing does not establish it as a shower chair, so it should not be used as one. Going the other way, a shower chair is not a full bedside commode replacement for every household: a narrower 14-inch seat, a 250 lb limit, and a 22-inch seat height that will not suit everyone. Many caregivers end up using both, each for its own job. Our guide to shower commode chairs goes deeper on the wet-room side.